- As part of a multiple-element arrangement, a vendor may agree to deliver software currently and to deliver additional software in the future. The additional deliverables may include upgrades/enhancements or additional software products. Additionally, a vendor may provide the customer with the right to exchange or return software, including the right to transfer software from one hardware platform or operating system to one or more other platforms or operating system (a platform-transfer right)
- Upgrades/enhancements. As part of a multiple-element arrangement, a vendor may agree to deliver software currently and provide the customer with an upgrade right for a specified upgrade/enhancement. The upgrade right may be evidenced by a specific agreement, commitment, or the vendor's established practice. (Rights to receive unspecified upgrades/enhancements on a when-and-if-available basis are PCS, as it has been redefined in this SOP.)
Specified Upgrade Right Versus Specified Additional Software Product - specified upgrade rights differs from the amount of revenue allocated to a specified additional software product. Determining if a software deliverable is an upgrade/enhancement or a product, the vendor should consider carefully the specific facts and circumstances on a case-by-case basis. Factors to consider would include the following:
- The significance of the differences in the features and functionality of the new deliverable from the vendor's existing products.
- Replacement of existing products - if the new deliverable is intended to substantially replace the vendor's existing products.
- The extent of development activities - if the new deliverable required a significant development effort, that may indicate that the deliverable is a product rather than an upgrade/enhancement.
- The relationship of the price of the new deliverable to the pricing for the vendor's existing products, including price discounts to existing customers - if the new deliverable is priced at an amount that is significantly higher than the price of the vendor's existing products, or if the existing users of the vendor's products are offered no discount or only an indicate that the deliverable is a product rather than an upgrade/enhancement.
- The manner in which the new deliverable is marketing.
- The product's name.
Rights to Specified Additional Undelivered Software Products - 97-2 distinguishes between the right to receive specified additional software products and the right to receive unspecified additional software products. A right to receive specified additional software products is accounted for as a separate element, which a right to receive unspecified additional software products is accounted for as a subscription. The SOP provides the following guidance:
- Additional Software Prodcuts. As part of a multiple-element arrangement, a vendor may agree to deliver software currently and deliver specified additional software products in the future. The rights to these additional products may be included either in the terms of a PCS arrangement or in a separate agreement. Even if the rights to the additional software products are included in a PCS arrangement, the revenue allocable to the additional software products should be accounted for separately from the PCS arrangement as an element of a multiple-element arrangement.
